All this suffering in Texas should not be happening. The grid in Texas is intact, they just don't have generation capacity. If Texas had remained part of the US grid, power from as far away as California, Washington, West Virginia, Tennessee, Florida, could be routed to Texas. Looking at the real-time data here, the US grid is running at more than 200 GW below capacity. There's enough power to hold up two states of Texas even if Texas had no generation at all. But we can't send them power.
Keep this in mind when rich people trick the public and politicians about privatization, and spout garbage like "going it alone, in keeping with the pioneering spirit of the USA". No. Organized cooperation is power. Going it alone is weakness.
Don't believe in cooperation? Study how the Roman army was organized. It was all about very tightly organized cooperation, starting with an individual soldier and those to his immediate left and right. This is how 8,000 Romans could take on 80,000 and methodically slaughter the 80,000 with zero losses.


95 people like this
marathon 🇨🇦, Danny ter Haar, kate :com: :ms_crow:, Nat🎱, Lindsay :pixel_battery_0X:, Furry Throw Pillows, stinky gaymer enby 🦄, Izalia Heck Mae, maple!~ (resident pokemon let's player), Trans Your Gasters, 🚭, skelly, USB/3.0 (like Fish; Roujo), Mads "🕳️ Theorist" Viande, mecca has a five guys, Ethan 🌒, Chazzzzz, eldritch, Lenalia!, may :pleroma:, Patashu (Classic Edition), leo homestuck, lunchgirl, prumm, Scott Mortimer, ✨phred🧙🏼♂️, walfischbucht, CBrachyrhynchos, crow@biteme.com, Jam, Ellory?, Karel P Kerezman, Mystery Babylon, Elda King, binchicken, the magpie, slash :cryknife:, Bubba, Andrew (R.S Admin), The Communist Exarch, Greg Kamprath, Not actually a cat??, Bad Badger, best :mow:, ƬᘿᖇᖇᎥ ᑕᖇᗩᑎᗷᘿᖇᖇᎩ 🇺🇸, Qyv (Lockdown 3 (Eng)), Tony Stark, generika, Charles Stanhope, Olivia, Natsumi, Q, Kelsey, mmu_man, Justin Myers, Fjords Cuomo, Bour Juwazey, 🐚 free-range space_onion 🐚, freshwater dog, Three Himbos in a Fursuit, 읽을 못해, Ray The Disaster Pan, Dipshit Official, Baloo Uriza 🏳️🌈🇺🇸, Webster Leone, Tomo in Saigon, sapphic giraffic, Monkey Kong, Nelson Pavlosky, AnarchoDork, Paul Gatling, clara, Thirst of their Name, Marmous, KWierso and 20 other people like this.
92 people reshared this
marathon 🇨🇦, Danny ter Haar, Gomez :baner:, Steven Hoefer🖋🚀🔆, kate :com: :ms_crow:, Nat🎱, Jordyn (Pi/Pem), blurred dragon :HeartAutism:, emotional support kobold, Lindsay :pixel_battery_0X:, stinky gaymer enby 🦄, Izalia Heck Mae, mx. j. w. logan, degenerate uniform star, maple!~ (resident pokemon let's player), Trans Your Gasters, 🚭, skelly, Mads "🕳️ Theorist" Viande, mecca has a five guys, Ethan 🌒, eldritch, fully automated space catgirls, mews >:3c, Patashu (Classic Edition), prumm, CBrachyrhynchos, Gustavs, entirely unable to name myself, nomad, Jam, Ellory?, bound, Mystery Babylon, Charles Thiccens, binchicken, Cosmo, oya, the shine of the ever, Dan Is Not Fixing Coin-Ops, Alex@rtnVFRmedia Suffolk UK, Fantom-Ass, Thomas Sturm, Bubba, The Communist Exarch, Not actually a cat??, Sugar-Lips Habasi, best :mow:, Qyv (Lockdown 3 (Eng)), ~~~~~los drogas~~~~~, People's Liberation Poster, Mars ☆he/him☆, Pinguin Techno Quantum Fairy, Natsumi, Q, The Doctor, Cybernomad, Kelsey, mmu_man, Mothman = Softman, Fjords Cuomo, Ronaldo V. Lobato, freshwater dog, Three Himbos in a Fursuit, 읽을 못해, Ray The Disaster Pan, Vivek, io, crasher35, kittens, marnanel, FriendofBernie, Ludovic Hirlimann, N. Ron Hubbard and 17 other people reshared this.
FrancisScottKey 2 weeks ago •
Cybernomad 2 weeks ago •
So I was wondering what did you mean when you talked about privatization.
2 people like this
Claes Wallin 🇸🇪🇭🇰 and OscillatingAgama like this.
Phil Landmeier (ᚠ) 1 week ago
The State of Texas sold all of its interests in the electrical grid (which is on public land) to private parties. Everything is owned privately in Texas. The impetus for this came from the private parties themselves -- a handful of wealthy investors who bribed politicians to get what they wanted, as usual in the USA.
They did this because if Texas as made independent from the US national grid, then federal regulations would not apply and they could build infrastructure more cheaply. That's how we ended up with non-winterized power plants and wind generators in Texas. The private owners wanted all the income but without making the investments in high quality equipment required by federal regulations. And, that's what they got.
When the winter... show more
The State of Texas sold all of its interests in the electrical grid (which is on public land) to private parties. Everything is owned privately in Texas. The impetus for this came from the private parties themselves -- a handful of wealthy investors who bribed politicians to get what they wanted, as usual in the USA.
They did this because if Texas as made independent from the US national grid, then federal regulations would not apply and they could build infrastructure more cheaply. That's how we ended up with non-winterized power plants and wind generators in Texas. The private owners wanted all the income but without making the investments in high quality equipment required by federal regulations. And, that's what they got.
When the winter storm was coming, utility officials lied right up to the last, when everything failed. They deliberately ignored the winter storm possibility -- something that's happened before. So they can't say they didn't know it was possible.
In the summertime especially, I watch this page on the EIA site that gathers real-time data from the nine agencies and breaks it down. https://www.eia.gov/beta/electricity/gridmonitor/dashboard/electric_overview/US48/US48
6 people like this
Claes Wallin 🇸🇪🇭🇰, Cybernomad, JauntyWunderKind, Puppy Pi, Billy Smith and Abbie Normal like this.
4 people reshared this
Rain 🚱, Puppy Pi, ᴛʜᴇʀᴜʀᴀɴ 🌐🏴 and Billy Smith reshared this.
Cybernomad 1 week ago •
Phil Landmeier (ᚠ) likes this.
OscillatingAgama 1 week ago •
The Second Battle of the Alamo: The Midnight Connection Richard D. Cudahy Natural Resources & Environment Vol. 10, No. 1 (Summer 1995) https://www.jstor.org/stable/40923434
@shuttersparks
Agris Viridi 1 week ago •
Phil Landmeier (ᚠ) likes this.
Phil Landmeier (ᚠ) 1 week ago
This is true even if all power is generated locally and there are no big power plants -- especially so, actually.
Big winter storm hits Chicago. Thick cloud deck over the whole region. Solar power is out. No wind. But in surrounding states a thousand or more miles away have plenty of sun and wind. They must route power to hold up the region around Chicago. The big grid is necessary.
And in the summertime, oh my. Watch the EIA site to see when demand climbs to 700 GW, every power plant is running at max, and it's a careful balancing act to keep everything going. It's only because there's a nationwide grid that everything can keep running. If you split that into hundreds of local systems, half the country would be blacked out in summer.
Bear in mind that despite the huge growth in renewables, wind generators as far as the... show more
This is true even if all power is generated locally and there are no big power plants -- especially so, actually.
Big winter storm hits Chicago. Thick cloud deck over the whole region. Solar power is out. No wind. But in surrounding states a thousand or more miles away have plenty of sun and wind. They must route power to hold up the region around Chicago. The big grid is necessary.
And in the summertime, oh my. Watch the EIA site to see when demand climbs to 700 GW, every power plant is running at max, and it's a careful balancing act to keep everything going. It's only because there's a nationwide grid that everything can keep running. If you split that into hundreds of local systems, half the country would be blacked out in summer.
Bear in mind that despite the huge growth in renewables, wind generators as far as the eye can see across Kansas and Wyoming, all of that is still a small fraction of power demand in the USA. The vast majority still comes from coal, gas, and nuclear.
Here in the little state of West Virginia, with a small population, we have 42 big coal-fired power plants because we stand on the world's largest coal deposit. Those power plants are what keep New York running in the summer.
I look forward eagerly to the proliferation of electric vehicles, but I'm very concerned about power generation to keep them all running. Demand is going to increase enormously and none of the local wiring is capable of handling the coming demand.
The bottom line is that independent microgrids have no chance of working. You can't practically build enough generation capacity to handle the peak demands of a certain small place. If you tried, then the average utilization would be like 20 percent. Nobody is going to invest in that. We would need five times to generation capacity that we have now. Sharing is the key. That's why the system is designed as it is.
For example, my wife and I come home from work at 5:30 PM. We plug in our cars and turn on the air conditioning. Wife starts cooking dinner, I take a shower. Power consumption of my house jumps from 1,000 watts to 25,000 watts. I have a big 3,000 watt solar power system and battery that let's me contribute power to the grid most of the time, but not at 5:30 PM. Every house in my city is doing just as I'm doing right now at 5:30.
So where does all that power come from? It comes from the states west / east of me that are in different time zones, that are not at the 5:30 PM rush. They feed gigawatts of power to my region. Later / earlier my region feeds power to them during their rush.
That's the only way the system holds up at all. Otherwise we'd need several times the generation capacity we have today, and most of it would be idle most of the time.
5 people like this
Claes Wallin 🇸🇪🇭🇰, bhaugen, Agris Viridi, Lindsay :pixel_battery_0X: and Gianf:) :elementary: like this.
bhaugen reshared this.
flaeky pancako 1 week ago •
it all boils down to backups and integrity tho, systems fail and we all need help sometimes.
flaeky pancako 1 week ago •
now if we had superconducting transmission lines, this would all be a different story.
Caleb James DeLisle 1 week ago •
1. Privatization is always highly risky because large transactions attract unscrupulous investors, and deals involving the state are susceptible to corruption.
2. Efficiency optimization compounds systemic risk.
Texas's electrical isolationism can be blamed in this particular case, but "one big happy grid" is not enough. There needs to be artificial incentive to over-build generation capacity because this problem can occur at any scale.
Claes Wallin 🇸🇪🇭🇰 likes this.
Claes Wallin 🇸🇪🇭🇰 reshared this.
bhaugen 1 week ago •
Ever so true, but you could expand on that a bit if you feel like it....
@shuttersparks
Caleb James DeLisle 1 week ago •
Claes Wallin 🇸🇪🇭🇰 likes this.
OscillatingAgama 1 week ago •
Imagine a man whose house was blown away by a hurricane because he was not rich enough to build a stronger one, selling his mother into slavery to do so. You think it was his fault for wanting to escape his mother's slavery. Slavery is just a form of regulation, isn't it?
Phil Landmeier (ᚠ) 5 days ago
There is no such thing as a free market other than as a theoretical concept that's useful in discussions of economics. The moment the first transaction occurs in a market, it is no long free. From there, capitalism always trends towards creating monopolies. That's the goal.
The primary function of any government is to regulate capitalism such that lively economic markets occur, monopolies are prevented, and the citizens are not harmed.
2 people like this
Halo and Gianf:) :elementary: like this.